An AI scribe listens to the consultation, turns speech into text and drafts a note for the doctor to check. That means a recording of one of the most private conversations a patient has, and usually a copy of it leaving the room for an outside company's servers. This page is about the step that should come first: patient consent for AI scribe recording, done simply, in a busy Indian OPD.
You get a short script you can read out, a checklist for the reception desk and the consult room, what India's data protection law and the medical ethics regulations say, and the questions to put to your scribe vendor. If you are still choosing a scribe, start with our buying guide for Indian doctors. For what happens to the audio step by step, see how AI medical scribes work, which also has a one-line consent script. This page gives a fuller one that also says where the recording goes and how long it is kept.
This is a general guide, not legal advice. Interpretations are marked "our reading". Speak to a lawyer about your own clinic.
Why this matters now
Two sets of lawsuits in the United States show what goes wrong when patients are not told clearly. They are allegations, not findings, and they are under US state laws that do not apply in India. They are useful because they show what patients say they were not told.
- Allegheny Health Network and Highmark Health, Pennsylvania. A proposed class action filed in early November 2026 in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas alleges that the health systems used Abridge, an ambient documentation tool, in exam rooms without informed consent, in breach of Pennsylvania's wiretapping law and doctor-patient confidentiality, according to ClassAction.org (10 November 2026) and TribLive. The complaint, as reported, alleges that the tool sent the recorded conversations to Abridge's servers and that Abridge used the recordings to train and improve its models. It alleges that some patients were told only that an AI tool would be used, not what would happen to the data, and that others were "told nothing at all". The defendants named in the report are the two health systems. A spokesman for them declined to comment, TribLive reported.
- MemorialCare, California. A proposed class action, Matulic v. Memorial Health Services, was filed on 6 August 2026 in the US District Court for the Northern District of California (case 3:26-cv-08206). The complaint we opened claims violations of California's Invasion of Privacy Act and its Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, among others. An earlier complaint filed on 8 April 2026 against Sutter Health and MemorialCare alleged a failure to obtain all-party consent before recordings were sent to Abridge's servers, Medscape reported. Medscape also reported that Abridge was not named as a defendant in that case, and that Abridge's own support materials tell clinicians to introduce the tool and obtain the patient's consent.
Our reading: in each case the complaint is less about the scribe and more about what the patient was told. A patient who hears "we use some AI" has not been told that the conversation is recorded, where it goes, who keeps it and for how long. The fix is a better explanation, given before the recording starts.
What Indian law asks for, and when
There are two different clocks.
The medical ethics duty applies now. Regulation 7.14 of the Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002, as published on the National Medical Commission's website, says a registered medical practitioner shall not disclose the secrets of a patient learnt in the exercise of the profession, except in a court of law under the orders of the presiding judge, where there is a serious and identified risk to a specific person or community, and for notifiable diseases. Regulation 2.2 says confidences entrusted by patients should never be revealed unless the law of the State requires it. Our reading: sending a full recording to an outside company is a disclosure the patient should know about. Telling them, and using the recording only to write their note, keeps you on the side of the duty of secrecy.
The DPDP Act's notice and consent duties start on 13 May 2027. The Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025 were published on 13 November 2025 (G.S.R. 846(E)). Rule 1(4) brings rules 3, 5 to 16, 22 and 23 into force eighteen months after publication, which, counted from that date, is 13 May 2027. The commencement notification for the Act, G.S.R. 843(E) of the same date, brings sections 3 to 5, sub-sections (1) to (8) and (10) of section 6, and sections 7 to 17 into force on the same eighteen-month step.
From that date, these sections matter most for a scribe:
- Section 5 (notice). Every request for consent must come with, or after, a notice that tells the patient what personal data you will process and why, how to withdraw consent and use their rights, and how to complain to the Data Protection Board.
- Rule 3 (what the notice must look like). It must stand on its own, be in clear and plain language, give an itemised description of the data and the specific purpose, and say how the patient can withdraw consent as easily as they gave it.
- Section 6 (consent). Consent must be free, specific, informed, unconditional and unambiguous, with a clear affirmative action, and limited to the data necessary for the purpose. The request must be in clear and plain language, with an option in English or a language in the Eighth Schedule to the Constitution. Withdrawal must be as easy as giving consent, and after a withdrawal the clinic must stop, and cause its processors to stop, within a reasonable time unless a law requires otherwise.
- Section 8(2) (the vendor contract). A Data Fiduciary may use a Data Processor only under a valid contract. Section 8(1) keeps the clinic responsible for what the processor does on its behalf. Rule 6(1)(f) expects that contract to include reasonable security safeguards.
- Section 8(7) (erasure). Unless a law requires the data to be kept, the clinic must erase personal data when the patient withdraws consent or when it is reasonable to assume the purpose is no longer served, and must cause its processor to erase it too.
- Section 9 (children). Verifiable consent of a parent or lawful guardian before processing a child's data. More on this below.
Our reading of the roles: the clinic, or the doctor running it, decides why and how the recording is made, so it is the Data Fiduciary. The scribe company processes the audio on the clinic's behalf, so it is a Data Processor. Our DPDP Act guide for clinics covers the rest of the Act, including breach reporting and the vendor questions for your clinic software.
A consent script you can read out
Keep it short. A patient waiting with fever does not want a lecture, but they do need the four facts the US complaints say were missing: it records, where it goes, who keeps it, and that they can say no. Fill in the brackets with what is true for your scribe, and have someone fluent turn it into the languages your patients speak. Section 6(3) of the Act expects the request to be available in English or a Schedule Eight language.
"Before we start: I use a computer tool that records our conversation to help me write your notes, so I can look at you instead of the screen. The recording goes to [name of the scribe company], which turns it into text and a draft note. I read and correct the note myself before it goes into your file. The recording is kept [for how long, or until when]. Only [who] can listen to it. You can say no, or ask me to stop it at any point, and your treatment will be exactly the same. Is that all right with you?"
Three things make it work:
- Ask before you press record, not after the patient has started talking.
- Wait for a clear yes. A nod while they are taking off a jacket is not one. If they hesitate, say you will write the notes yourself today.
- Write one line in the note: "AI scribe explained, patient agreed to recording", or "declined", with the time.
If you see the same patients often, you do not need the full script each visit. Our reading: a short reminder ("The recorder is on again today, is that fine?") and the note line are enough, as long as the first explanation was clear and nothing about the tool has changed. If you change vendor, or the recording starts being kept longer or used for something new, explain again.
The reception notice
The consult room is not the only place to tell patients. Put a short notice at reception and in your registration form, so that the doctor's question is not the first time the patient hears of it. A notice under Rule 3 has to stand on its own and describe the data and the purpose. For the scribe, a few lines can cover it:
"Some doctors here use an AI scribe that records the consultation to draft the doctor's notes. The doctor will ask you before recording. You can say no and your care will not change. Recordings go to [scribe company] for processing and are kept for [period]. To ask about your data, contact [name and number]."
Have your lawyer read it before 13 May 2027, and keep a dated copy of each version you put up.
Checklist: before the first recording
- Know where the audio goes. Which company transcribes it, which company drafts the note, and in which countries their servers sit. Ask for the list of sub-processors in writing.
- Sign a written contract with the vendor. Section 8(2) needs a valid contract for a processor. It should say the vendor processes data only on your instructions, how it keeps the data secure (Rule 6(1)(f)), how fast it tells you about a breach, and how it deletes data when you leave.
- Ask about model training, and get the answer in the contract. Does the vendor, or anyone it sends the audio to, use recordings or transcripts to train or improve models? If yes, the patient has to be told, and our reading is that this needs its own specific consent, because section 6(1) limits consent to a specified purpose.
- Decide how long audio is kept, and why. See the next section.
- Decide who can listen. Which staff logins can play a recording, and whether the vendor's support staff can.
- Brief your team. Receptionists, nurses and any doctor who uses the tool should know the script, the note line and what to do when a patient says no.
- Update the reception notice and the registration form.
Checklist: every consultation
- Ask before recording, using the script.
- Note the answer and the time in the visit record.
- Offer to pause for sensitive parts, such as a physical examination, sexual or mental health history, or anything the patient asks to keep off the recording. Our reading: the patient's request to pause is a partial withdrawal under section 6(4) and should be honoured at once.
- Check who else is speaking. Relatives in the room are recorded too. Tell them, and if one objects, pause.
- Read the draft against what was said before you accept it. The doctor remains responsible for the signed note.
Patients who say no
Offer the ordinary way: write or type the note yourself. Our reading: consent that is free, under section 6(1), means the refusal changes nothing else about the visit. Do not move the patient to the back of the queue, do not suggest the doctor will be slower or less careful, and do not charge anything different. Note the refusal so that the next visit starts with the right expectation. If the patient agreed and then asks you to stop, stop the recording, and ask your vendor what happens to the part already captured. Section 6(6) asks the clinic to cause its processors to stop processing after a withdrawal, unless a law requires otherwise.
Children and patients who cannot decide for themselves
Section 9(1) of the Act asks for verifiable consent of a parent before a child's personal data is processed, and of the lawful guardian for a person with a disability who has one. The Act defines a child as someone under 18. Rule 10 of the DPDP Rules sets out how a Data Fiduciary checks that the person giving consent as a parent is an identifiable adult.
There is a health exemption, and it is narrower than it looks. Rule 12 and Part A of the Fourth Schedule say section 9(1) does not apply to a clinical establishment or healthcare professional where processing is restricted to providing health services to the child, to the extent necessary for the protection of her health. Our reading: treating a child and keeping the child's record fall within that. A scribe recording is a way of writing the note faster, and it is hard to argue it is necessary to protect the child's health. So ask the parent or guardian who brought the child, use the same script, and note who agreed. An adolescent who wants to speak to the doctor alone, or does not want a recording, is a good reason to switch it off.
These duties start on 13 May 2027. Paediatric and family practices should walk through this part with their lawyer now.
Deleting the audio after the note is signed
Many clinics will want the recording gone once the doctor has checked and signed the note. Section 8(7)(a) points the same way: unless a law requires you to keep it, personal data should be erased when it is reasonable to assume the purpose is no longer served, and your processor must erase it too.
Our reading: the answer depends on what your clinic says the recording is for. If the recording is only a drafting aid, the purpose arguably ends when the note is signed, and deleting it then is the cleaner position. If your clinic treats the recording as part of the medical record, for example to check later what was said, then you need a reason to keep it, a period, and a notice that says so. Decide which it is, write it into your notice and the vendor contract, and do not leave stray copies in downloads folders or chat apps. Medical record retention under other laws, such as your state's clinical establishment rules, is a separate question to settle with your lawyer.
Then check what your software actually does. Ask the vendor: Is audio deleted when the note is signed, or kept? Is that a setting the clinic controls? Are segments, backups and copies held by sub-processors deleted at the same time? Can you get that in writing?
Where Medabha fits, and what it does not do
We would rather you know exactly how our own AI medical scribe behaves than assume it fits this checklist. As it stands today:
- Recording starts only when the doctor presses Start, and on a phone a small recording bar stays on screen while it runs. The doctor can pause the recording.
- Audio is uploaded over HTTPS and encrypted on the server's disk once saved, as our security page explains.
- Audio is kept after signing, so the doctor can play the visit back. Deleting it automatically on signing is not a per-clinic setting yet. Before a draft is applied and the visit signed, the doctor can discard a recording, which removes its audio. Discarding a draft consultation removes its recordings, and deleting the clinic account removes consultation audio and transcripts. Visit audio is not included in the daily backups.
- Who processes it. Our privacy policy lists Sarvam AI for speech-to-text and OpenAI for drafting the note from the transcript, and says some processors handle data outside India. For patient records and recordings, the clinic is the Data Fiduciary and Medabha is a Data Processor acting on its instructions.
- There is no separate consent record for the recording. Medabha shows a short data notice when a patient is registered, in English, Hindi or Bengali, and records that it was acknowledged. That notice does not mention recording or the AI scribe. The scribe itself does not ask for or store the patient's consent to record. The clinic has to ask, and the note line in this guide is how you keep a record of it.
- The draft does not reach the chart until the doctor applies it, and the prescriber stays responsible for what is signed.
If you need audio deleted on signing for your clinic today, ask us at care@medabha.com, and do not tell patients it is deleted unless it is.
A note on the NHA voice scribe
India's National Health Authority demonstrated an ambient AI voice scribe at a review meeting in Kolkata on 5 and 6 November 2026, and the official account says doctors review and confirm the records. We covered what was and was not announced in NHA ambient AI voice scribe and PM-JAY claims. Nothing in those sources removes a private clinic's own duty to tell its patients before a consultation is recorded.
Summary: the one-page version
| Step | What to do | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Notice at reception | Short notice: recording, purpose, company, period, contact | DPDP Act s.5 and Rule 3, from 13 May 2027 |
| Ask before recording | Read the script, wait for a clear yes | DPDP Act s.6(1); IMC Regulations 2.2 and 7.14, now |
| Write it down | One line in the visit note, with the time | Our reading: proof that you asked |
| Patient says no | Write the note yourself; nothing else changes | DPDP Act s.6(1), free consent |
| Patient withdraws | Stop at once; ask the vendor to stop | DPDP Act s.6(4) and s.6(6) |
| Child | Ask the parent or guardian; do not rely on the health exemption | DPDP Act s.9(1); Rules 10 and 12, Fourth Schedule |
| Vendor | Written contract, security, breach notice, deletion, training answer | DPDP Act s.8(1) and s.8(2); Rule 6(1)(f) |
| Audio after signing | Decide the purpose; delete when it is served, unless a law says keep | DPDP Act s.8(7) |
Sources
- Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (22 of 2023), sections 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9, Gazette of India copy on meity.gov.in, read 17 November 2026.
- Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025, G.S.R. 846(E), 13 November 2025, rules 1, 3, 6, 10 and 12 and the Fourth Schedule, on meity.gov.in, read 17 November 2026.
- Commencement notification G.S.R. 843(E), 13 November 2025, on meity.gov.in, read 17 November 2026.
- Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002, regulations 2.2 and 7.14, on nmc.org.in, read 17 November 2026.
- Olivia DeRicco, ClassAction.org, 10 November 2026: Allegheny Health Network, Highmark Health used AI documentation tool without consent, class action suit claims. Allegations only.
- Paula Reed Ward, TribLive, November 2026: Lawsuit: AI recording tool used by AHN, Highmark violates patient rights. Allegations only.
- Matulic v. Memorial Health Services, Inc., US District Court, Northern District of California, case 3:26-cv-08206, complaint filed 6 August 2026, docket on PacerMonitor. Allegations only.
- Steph Weber, Medscape, 16 April 2026: Patients sue two more health systems over AI scribe use, lack of consent. Allegations only.
This is a general guide, not legal advice. Information as of 17 November 2026, Asia/Calcutta. If a later notification, rule or court decision says something different, follow that.
Frequently asked questions
Is a spoken yes enough, or does the patient need to sign a form before an AI scribe records?
Section 6(1) of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 describes valid consent as free, specific, informed, unconditional and unambiguous, given with a clear affirmative action. It does not, in the text we read, require a signature on paper. Our reading: a clear spoken yes after a plain explanation can be a clear affirmative action, but you need to be able to show later that you asked. Write one line in the visit note, such as "AI scribe explained, patient agreed to recording", with the time. Sections 5 and 6 start on 13 May 2027, so this is preparation for that date as well as good practice now. This is a general guide, not legal advice.
Do I need a parent's consent before an AI scribe records a child's consultation?
Section 9(1) of the DPDP Act asks a Data Fiduciary to obtain verifiable consent of a parent before processing a child's personal data, and the Act treats anyone under 18 as a child. Rule 12 and Part A of the Fourth Schedule of the DPDP Rules, 2025 exempt a clinical establishment or healthcare professional from section 9(1), but only where processing is restricted to providing health services to the child, to the extent necessary for the protection of her health. Our reading: a scribe recording is a documentation aid, so do not assume the exemption covers it. Ask the parent or guardian who is with the child, and note their answer. This is a general guide, not legal advice.
What should a clinic do when a patient says no to the AI scribe?
Do not start the recording, and write the note by hand or by typing, as you would without a scribe. Section 6(1) of the DPDP Act describes consent as free, so the patient's care, queue position and fee should not change because they declined. If the patient agrees and later asks you to stop, stop the recording at once. Section 6(4) gives the right to withdraw consent at any time, as easily as it was given, and section 6(6) asks the Data Fiduciary to stop its processors too. Note the refusal or withdrawal in the visit record so the next person does not ask again without reason. This is a general guide, not legal advice.
Does Medabha delete the consultation recording after the doctor signs the note?
No, not today. In Medabha the visit audio is kept after signing so the doctor can play it back, and deleting it automatically on signing is not a per-clinic setting yet. Before you apply a draft and sign, you can discard an unwanted recording, which removes its audio. Discarding a draft consultation also removes its recordings, and deleting the clinic account removes consultation audio and transcripts. Medabha's privacy page lists Sarvam AI for speech-to-text and OpenAI for drafting the note from the transcript. The scribe does not record a separate patient consent for the recording, so the clinic has to ask and note it.
Try Medabha in your own clinic
AI medical scribe, WhatsApp prescriptions, specialty charts and a built-in clinic website, set up in minutes.
Start 14-day free trial Prefer a walkthrough? Book a demoNo card needed.
This article is general information about clinic software and documentation workflows, not medical, legal or regulatory advice. Check current requirements with the relevant authority before making compliance decisions.